The Latest

THE INFERNAL DEVICES: CLOCKWORK ANGEL manga review

Earlier than its announced release date the long awaited THE INFERNAL DEVICES: CLOCKWORK ANGEL manga by Cassandra Clare and Yen Press has hit the book stores or can now be ordered online. If you are still uncertain about buying the manga maybe this following review will help you.

First off all let me say that I used to be a manga fan as a teenager. I grew up reading comic books and then discovered mangas. When I read that CLOCKWORK ANGEL was turned into a manga I was pretty curious and naturally I preordered it. I got my copy a few days early and took a break from rereading CITY OF LOST SOULS to read about Tessa, Will and Jem’s adventures in London.

Our first look is at one Mr William Herondale. To me he resembles a magician because of his red cape and the stele which looks like a very thin wand. The second picture of Will is much more promising. This time there is more action. Will is holding a seraph blade and ravens are flying beside him. In the background there are two towers, St Paul’s Cathedral and Victorian London.

The first 3 pages of the manga are in color, the rest is black and white. CLOCKWORK ANGEL’s 20 chapters and the epilogue are shown in 8 chapters and on roughly 240 pages. The manga starts where the book starts: Will and Jem are investigating the murder of a young girl and Tessa is arriving in London.  I think you all know the rest of the book so I won’t mention the plot.

The story is very easy to follow and you get sucked into Victorian London, its Shadowhunters and Downworlders.

In the following I’ve written down some bullet points of the things I liked and disliked:

What I liked:

  • The buildings: the exterior and interior of the Institute (the library looked amazing) or the meeting place of the Pandemonium Club.
  • Brother Enoch – wow. He looked amazing and so creepy! I cannot wait to see more of the Silent Brothers in THE MORTAL INSTRUMENTS: CITY OF BONES.
  • The interludes when the characters – mostly Will and Tessa – didn’t look like their usual manga selves but almost like chibi versions.
  • The automatons. They looked great, so realistic but still devoid of any emotion.
  • Tessa: she was so pretty and I absolutely loved her hair. To be honest all the girls had great hair in the manga!
  • Will (so adorable as a little boy) and Jem: Good luck, Tessa! I know I wouldn’t be able to make a decision between these two when they look so handsome.
  • The kiss. I don’t think I have to elucidate.

What I disliked:

  • The way a few characters (Henry, Charlotte and Magnus) were drawn. I was disappointed, I admit it. I won’t elaborate because you can see for yourselves if you decide to buy the manga.
  • Unfortunately, you don’t start at the other end of the book (the usual manga reading style) but at the left end like a conventional comic book. I would have preferred to read it like a real manga, from right to left.
  • SPOILER! No A TALE OF TWO CITIES. For me the book is a very important part of THE INFERNAL DEVICES and I was sad that it wasn’t mentioned when Will and Tessa are in the Institute’s library.

Last but not least you can have a look at a few selected pictures of CLOCKWORK ANGEL to make up your mind:

image

Tessa and her angel

image

Will

image

Little Will

image

Jem

image

Magnus

Chibi Tessa and chibi Will

All pictures belong to Cassandra Clare and Yen Press.

And now SOUND OFF in the comments. Have you already bought the manga or are you going to buy it? What do you think of it?

About Cathrin (847 Articles)
Admin and writer for TMI Source and 'The Shadowhunter Chronicles' lover extraordinaire. Fangirls over books, history, German football, movies and fictional characters.

12 Comments on THE INFERNAL DEVICES: CLOCKWORK ANGEL manga review

  1. God, you’re definitely right about Magnus!
    I must admit, I’m not very big on manga to start with, but seeing as this was Clockwork Angel, I was prepared to purchase it. However, after seeing how the characters look I will give it a miss and stick to the much better (in my opinion anyway!) CoB graphic novel! And I’ve always hated those chibis in manga. Definitely not for me 🙂

    • AWildFangirlAppears // October 28, 2012 at 6:44 PM // Reply

      :O How can you not like manga? The artwork is way more pretty than in the CoB comic, they all look 30 and ugly as a Ravener!

      • I agree that the manga artwork is better than the CoB graphic novel, and I think the little chibi characters are adorable! But I’m definitely not liking the look of Magnus in the Clockwork Angel manga.

  2. Despite the fact that Magnus shown here is not how I pictured him at all, I really love how Will and Jem look (especially Jem), and I do have an appreciation for manga style. I will give it a go.

  3. My review is going up tomorrow for my Mundane Monday post. I totally agree with your likes and dislikes. I felt the same way. I LOVE how Tessa, Jem and Will were drawn. This one I’d definitely recommend to ID fans.

  4. So cuttttteee!!!!!
    I wish magnus was interpreted better though too.

  5. can’t wait to read ir!

  6. Already ordered. I’M READY! HIT ME, UPS! (Not with the truck please) I’m not sure about Magnus’ hair, but his face looks pretty good to me. I used to read manga, but stopped for a while and now I’m getting back into it. Will and Jem look FINE. It looks way better than the CoB graphic novel and I adore those chibis! They have a strong grasp on my soul.

  7. cassandraday // October 31, 2012 at 2:54 PM // Reply

    Magnus’s hair is so.. Not Magnus @_@
    Maybe because it was pre-Camille? (If that makes any sense.)

  8. Chibi Will!! OMG!!! xD Little Will seems better than older Will, I just dont like his eyes. I mean I’ve read lots of manga, I know the hate I’m gonna get but his eyes just dont look good to me :/

  9. ShadowhunterObsession // December 30, 2012 at 10:02 PM // Reply

    *sobbing* WAAAAH!!!!!!!!!!! THEY MESSED UP MAGNUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  10. It’s not a manga but a manghwa (korean manga). So, normally, it’s not supposed to start at the end. Just so you know…

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. 2012 Year In Review: THE INFERNAL DEVICES « TMI Source

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: